House amendment makes the following changes to the 3rd edition.
Makes a technical changes, correcting the stated number of members of the Joint Legislative Study Committee on Property Insurance Rate Making to 16, reflecting already listed committee membership.
PROPERTY INSURANCE FAIRNESS.
|View NCGA Bill Details||2015-2016 Session|
AN ACT TO INCREASE THE FAIRNESS AND EQUITY OF PROPERTY INSURANCE RATE MAKING IN NORTH CAROLINA BY REQUIRING THAT CERTAIN PROPERTY INSURANCE DATA BE MADE AVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC; BY PROVIDING THE NORTH CAROLINA INSURANCE UNDERWRITING ASSOCIATION THE AUTHORITY TO HAVE ISSUED TAX-EXEMPT BONDS TO COVER LOSS-RELATED LIABILITIES; BY REFORMING CONSENT TO RATE PRACTICES; BY REQUIRING THAT CATASTROPHE MODELING USED FOR PROPERTY RATE-MAKING PURPOSES MORE ACCURATELY REFLECT POTENTIAL IMPACTS IN NORTH CAROLINA; AND BY CREATING THE JOINT LEGISLATIVE STUDY COMMITTEE ON PROPERTY INSURANCE RATE MAKING.Intro. by Millis, Lewis, Hager.
SOG comments (2):
Long Title Change
House committee substitute to the 1st edition makes changes to the long title. The original title was as follows:
AN ACT TO INCREASE THE FAIRNESS AND EQUITY OF PROPERTY INSURANCE RATE MAKING IN NORTH CAROLINA BY REQUIRING THAT CERTAIN PROPERTY INSURANCE DATA BE MADE AVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC; BY PROVIDING THE COMMISSIONER WITH THE AUTHORITY TO ORDER A DECREASE IN RATES IN A PROPERTY INSURANCE RATE-MAKING PROCEEDING; BY PROVIDING THE NORTH CAROLINA INSURANCE UNDERWRITING ASSOCIATION THE AUTHORITY TO HAVE ISSUED TAX-EXEMPT BONDS TO COVER LOSS-RELATED LIABILITIES; BY REFORMING CONSENT TO RATE PRACTICES; BY REQUIRING THAT CATASTROPHE MODELING USED FOR PROPERTY RATE-MAKING PURPOSES MORE ACCURATELY REFLECT POTENTIAL IMPACTS IN NORTH CAROLINA; AND BY CREATING THE JOINT LEGISLATIVE STUDY COMMITTEE ON PROPERTY INSURANCE RATE MAKING.
Tue, 10 Mar 2015 House: Filed
Wed, 11 Mar 2015 House: Passed 1st Reading
Wed, 11 Mar 2015 House: Ref to the Com on Insurance, if favorable, Finance
Tue, 28 Apr 2015 House: Reptd Fav Com Substitute
Tue, 28 Apr 2015 House: Re-ref Com On Finance
Thu, 7 May 2015 House: Reptd Fav Com Sub 2
Thu, 7 May 2015 House: Cal Pursuant Rule 36(b)
Thu, 7 May 2015 House: Placed On Cal For 05/12/2015
Tue, 12 May 2015 House: Amend Adopted A1
Tue, 12 May 2015 House: Passed 2nd Reading
Wed, 13 May 2015 House: Amend Failed A2
Wed, 13 May 2015 House: Passed 3rd Reading
Wed, 13 May 2015 House: Ordered Engrossed
Thu, 14 May 2015 House: Regular Message Sent To Senate
Thu, 14 May 2015 Senate: Regular Message Received From House
Thu, 14 May 2015 Senate: Passed 1st Reading
Thu, 14 May 2015 Senate: Ref To Com On Insurance
Summary date: May 12 2015 - View Summary
Summary date: May 7 2015 - View Summary
House committee substitute makes the following changes to the 2nd edition:
Amends proposed GS 58-36-15(d2), making technical, organizational, and clarifying changes. Provides that the submission of catastrophic wind and hail information must be submitted by companies to the Department of Insurance (Department) and the NC Rate Bureau (Bureau) pursuant to a data call by the Department for losses caused by a specific catastrophic hurricane event. (previously, required the Bureau to submit catastrophic wind and hail information to the Department). Makes conforming changes.
Deletes all of the provisions of proposed GS 58-45A-55 now providing that the interest on bonds that are issued by the Recovery Finance Authority pursuant to GS Chapter 58, Article 45A are exempt from taxation under the specified provisions.
Amends GS 58-45-47 concerning the limitations of the actual levying of any catastrophe recovery charge, providing that amounts pledged pursuant to catastrophe recovery charges under specified financing agreements cannot result in actual levying of a catastrophe recovery charge until after the NC Insurance Underwriting Association (Association) has incurred a deficit and until after the requirements of GS 58-45-47 have been met (previously required the Association to have incurred a deficit and the Commissioner of Insurance to approve implementation of the Association's catastrophe recovery charge).
Amends proposed GS 58-36-30(b1) making a technical change.
Amends the proposed language in GS 58-36-10(3) concerning the method of rate making and the factors considered, to provide that if the Bureau presents any modeled hurricane losses based on a commercial hurricane simulation computer model with a property insurance rate filing then it must present data from more than one such model. Requires models to consider the NC Building codes for residential construction (previously, if the Bureau presents any modeled losses with a property insurance rate filing, then it must also present data from more than one catastrophe model. Also required the models to be based on maximum load designs as contained in the NC State Building Codes).
Makes clarifying changes to provisions concerning the Joint Legislative Study Committee on Property Insurance Rate Making (Committee) and amends the membership of the committee to provide that the Speaker of the House and the President Pro Tempore of the Senate are also to appoint three public members each to the Committee, as specified, in addition to the five members that are to be appointed from each chamber.
Makes clarifying changes to the effective date provisions.
Summary date: Apr 28 2015 - View Summary
House committee substitute makes the following changes to the 1st edition.
Amends the long title.
Deletes proposed GS Chapter 58, Article 10, Part 10, Property Insurance Rate Clarity.
Deletes proposed changes to GS 58-36-20, concerning Commissioner approval of rate levels.
Enacts GS 58-36-15(d2), directing the Rate Bureau to submit and report specified information on losses related to homeowner's insurance rate filings, including direct incurred losses, direct earned premiums, house years, and statewide expenses for the most recent five years. Requires submission of catastrophic wind and hail information. Requires the Department of Insurance (Department) to post all information received on its website. Also provides that information reported is considered a trade secret and must be treated as confidential information. Sets out procedures and requirements for the release of the information pursuant to a court order.
Amends proposed GS Chapter 58, Article 45A, Recovery Finance Authority, to include loss adjustment expenses as one of the expenses that is considered in calculating deficits for the purposes of receiving funding from the NC Recovery Finance Authority. Makes conforming changes.
Amends GS 58-45-47, concerning deficit events, making technical and clarifying changes. Provides that catastrophe recovery charge amounts remaining after payment of debt must first be remitted to the NC Recovery Finance Authority for expenses incurred and then any remaining charge amounts must go to the NC Insurance Underwriting Association (was, must be refunded to policyholders as approved).
Amends GS 159-89 and 159-96, replacing references to the "NC Guaranty Association" with "NC Insurance Underwriting Association."
Amends GS 58-36-30(b) concerning deviations in certain rates established by the Rate Bureau, to provide that the subsection only applies to insurance nonfleet private passenger motor vehicles coverage, with the exception of liability coverage (previously, only applied to insurance against theft for physical damage to nonfleet private passenger motor vehicles and for loss costs and residual market rate filings for workers' compensation and employers' liability insurance written in connection with those loss costs and rate filings). Requires insurers to give reasonable notice to the insured by including the specified language in 10 point type on the insured's written consent to rate form. Requires the form to be included on any renewal of or endorsement to the policy for any subsequent rate increase about the manual rate following the initial written consent of an insured, provided that no further written consent is required after the initial consent to rate is received (was, no written consent of the insured was required on any renewal or endorsement of a policy if the policy stated that the rates are greater than those applicable in North Carolina).
Summary date: Mar 10 2015 - View Summary
Amends GS Chapter 58 by creating new Part 10 (Property Insurance Rate Clarity). Provides that each insurer authorized to conduct property insurance business in North Carolina, the NC Insurance Underwriting Association, and the NC Joint Underwriting Association must annually submit to the Department of Insurance (Department) computations of the total amount of direct incurred losses, the number of policies in force, and the direct earned premiums for the prior calendar year, including policies written or serviced under GS Chapter 58, Articles 45 and 46. This information will be reported by rate territory and by type of property insurance policy. Provides that for this Part, property insurance also includes condo insurance, dwelling fire policies, renter's or tenant's insurance, and mobile home and manufactured housing property insurance.
Also requires each insurer authorized to conduct homeowners insurance in North Carolina to annually submit to the Department the total amount of direct incurred losses and the number of policies in force, by rate territory, for the prior calendar year for perils including fire, wind and hail, and all other perils.
Requires each insurer authorized to transact property insurance in North Carolina to provide information required pursuant to GS 58-10-705(a) for calendar years 2009 through 2014. Based on this information, the Department will compile aggregate totals and post such totals to the Department website no later than December 1, 2015.
Allows the Commissioner of Insurance (Commissioner) to waive, modify, or extend for an additional time period for good cause the reporting requirements imposed by this act when the waiver is requested in writing. Describes what constitutes good cause and how to demonstrate it. Failing to timely comply with the reporting requirements triggers a notice by the Department and any delay in complying past the 90th day after notice and hearing will require an insurer to pay a civil penalty of $2,500 per month to the Commissioner until the date of compliance. Establishes that information reported to the Department pursuant to this act is considered a trade secret, as found in GS 66-152, and will be treated as confidential information.
The above changes are effective when the act becomes law, with any any current year requirements applying to the 2015 and subsequent calendar years.
Amends GS 58-36-20, establishing that in the event the Commissioner finds that the proposed rates are excessive, the Commissioner will issue an order disapproving the filing and will specify the appropriate rate level that may be used (was, will specify the overall rates that may be used by the members of the Bureau instead of the rates proposed by the Bureau filing).
Amends GS Chapter 58 to enact a new Article 45A (Recovery Finance Authority). Provides legislative findings establishing reasons for the Recovery Finance Authority, including the likelihood that one or more hurricanes or catastrophic events could surpass the financial abilities of the NC Insurance Underwriting Association (Association). Provides eight definitions for use in this Article, including assessment, bonds, and catastrophe recovery charge.
Creates the North Carolina Recovery Finance Authority (Authority), constituted as a public agency, located in the Department, with specified powers related to the financing of deficits of the Association due to catastrophic events. Provides for a nine-member board with two members each appointed by the Speaker of the House and the Senate President Pro Tempore, two members appointed by the Governor, two members appointed by the Association, and one is the Commissioner of Insurance, with the Chair of the Authority to be appointed by the Board. Provides for staggered terms of the initial members and the members thereafter. Provides further requirements for the Authority regarding removal of board members, conflicts of interest and ethics, and compensation. Requires the Authority to create bylaws concerning organizational and administrative matters of the board.
Specifies 18 powers of the Authority, including to invest the proceeds of bonds of the Authority that are pending disbursement or other idle funds and to apply for, accept, and administer loans and grants of money or real or personal property from the United States or any federal agency, the state, or other public or private sources.
Exempts property owned by the Authority from taxation.
Authorizes the issuance of bonds by the Authority as if the Authority was a municipality, with all the powers and protections afforded to municipalities under the State and Local Government Revenue Bond Act. Specifies investment vehicles authorized for use, through contract, by the Authority, including interest rate swap agreements and contracts to exchange cash flows. Specifies provisions for and limitations of entering into such investment contracts. Provides certain obligations of the Authority if the Association requests the issuance of bonds. Provides provisions for and limitations on issued bonds, including that the bonds are not secured by the full faith and credit of the state, that bonds are considered securities in which varied individuals and institutions can invest, and that they are exempt from all state, county, and municipal taxation or assessment.
Amends GS 58-45-47 concerning deficit events, providing that when the Association expects to incur losses and expenses exceeding available surplus or other sources, taking into consideration account sources committed with respect to losses and expenses expected from prior events (previously, did not include clarifying language regarding losses and expenses from prior events), the Association is authorized to issue a nonrecouple assessment on its members. When it is expected that losses incurred will exceed sources of funding, including permissible member assessments, the Association must also immediately give notice to the Authority that a deficit event has incurred. Provides that upon such notice the Association must provide evidence in regards to its estimates of total losses and expenses expected to be incurred within the calendar year and funding amounts available to it. Such evidence and material is required to be available to the Commissioner for review. Provides that upon certification of the deficit event, the Association can determine the appropriate means of financing the deficit, which can include financing from the Authority. Provides and amends permissible actions if it is determined that losses and expenses incurred have risen to the level necessary for the imposition of a catastrophe recovery charge, including the new action that the Association can inform the Authority and the Commission that it will assign specified obligations to pay claims to the Authority and act as agent for the Authority to collect catastrophe recovery charges and direct such amounts to the Authority. Adds new language concerning the Catastrophe Recovery Charge providing that when charged pursuant to this section, it be will a uniform percentage of written premiums as prescribed by the Commissioner, not to exceed an aggregate amount of 10% of the annual policy premium on any one policy of insurance, imposed on policyholders from the Association and the FAIR Plan. Provides for periodic revision of the Catastrophe Recovery Charge as well as provisions concerning the cessation, repayment, and limitations of the Catastrophe Recovery Charge. Makes various technical, organizational, and conforming changes.
Amends GS 120-123 to provide that no member of the General Assembly can serve on the Authority board.
Amends GS 159-81(3) to provide that the financing of deficits by the Authority can be considered a revenue bond project for the purposes pursuant to the section.
Amends GS 159-83 concerning powers associated with revenue bonds, providing that the Authority has the power to contract for the charging of catastrophe recovery charges, including covenanting to make such charged as necessary for the payment of revenue bonds as well as having the power to pledge and assign its rights to the making, revising, receiving, and enforcing such changes for its revenue bonds.
Amends GS 159-89, making conforming changes concerning special covenants of issuers of revenue bonds, providing the Association can enter into agreements to assign obligations to pay claims of amounts in excess of its losses and expenses that exceed available funding to the Authority as well as act as its agent in the recovery of such imposed charges.
Amends GS 159-90(a)(1) concerning the maturity dates of bonds, providing that maturity dates for bonds issued by the Authority will be related to the structuring of the repayment of proceeds rather than the facilities paid for, with an overall limit of 40 years.
Amends GS 159-93, updating the agreement of the state to not limit or alter the rights vested in the state or any municipality, at the time of issuance of bonds or notes, to include the collection of catastrophe recovery charges.
Amends GS 159-95 concerning the approval of state agencies for certain revenue bond projects, providing that bonds issued by the Authority do not require the approval of the Department of Insurance except to the extent catastrophe recovery charges require action pursuant to GS 58-45-47.
Amends GS 159-96 concerning geographical limitations for enterprises financed by revenue bonds, providing that no such geographical or territorial limitation exists on the use of proceeds of bonds issued by the Authority other than for payment of a deficit related to a catastrophic event affecting property covered under insurance policies issued by the NC Insurance Guaranty Association.
Amends GS 58-36-30 concerning deviations in certain rates established by the Rate Bureau (Bureau), providing that the provisions of subsection (b) only apply to insurance against theft for physical damage to nonfleet private passenger motor vehicles and for loss costs and residual market rate filings for workers' compensation and employers' liability insurance written in connection with those loss costs and rate filings. Enacts new subsection (b1), which applies only to insurance against loss to residential real property with not more than four housing units and provides that a rate in excess of that established by the Bureau can be charged by an insurer on any specific risk if the higher rate is charged pursuant to rules adopted by the Commissioner and is based on sound actuarial principles as well as is charged with the knowledge and written consent of the insured. Includes other provisions concerning this permissible higher rate.
Amends GS 58-36-10, concerning the method of rate making and the factors considered, providing that if the Bureau presents any modeled losses with a property insurance rate filing, then it must also present data from more than one catastrophe model. Additionally, the models must be based on maximum load designs as contained in the NC State Building Codes.
Creates the Joint Legislative Study Committee on Property Insurance Rate Making (Committee), consisting of 10 members appointed as specified. Provides three areas that the Committee must study, including the structure, function, and operations of the Rate Bureau and the prevalence and geographic distribution of property insurance policies. Includes provisions concerning the appointment of cochairs and filing of vacancies on the Committee and details the Committee's powers and the staffing for the Committee. Requires the Committee to submit an interim report to the 2015 General Assembly when it reconvenes in 2016, with a final report being submitted to the 2017 General Assembly. After submitting the report the Committee is terminated.
Amends GS 58-45-5(2c), making technical deletions and clarifying changes.
Includes a severability clause.
Unless otherwise noted above, effective July 1, 2015.
Bill as filed is identical to S 208 as filed 3/10/15.